Two of her childrenmadison and estonindicated that jefferson was their father, and. Born into slavery by his mothers status, he was freed by the will of jefferson in 1826. James madison hemings january 18, 1805 november 28, 1877 was the son of the mixedrace slave sally hemings. Madison even acknowledged that thomas jefferson didnt treat him and his siblings like. Jeffersonhemings revisited national association of scholars. Thomas jefferson owned hemings, who was black, and the hemings familys.
Note that according to thomas jeffersons farm book, sally never had a son by the name of tom. Madison hemings provided an account of his mothers life that was published in. I particularly liked the textual analysis of previous historians work or lack thereof on this topic. The dna testing found no genetic link between the hemings and carr descendants. A dna test of hemings descendants revealed genetic evidence indicating that jefferson fathered her children. Dna vs book of mormon incredible new evidence youtube.
In a memoir published in an ohio newspaper in 1873, madison hemings claimed to be jeffersons child. Genetic attacks on the book of mormon focus on the fact that amerindian dna seems closest to asian dna, and not dna from the middle east or jewish dna. Four of hemings children lived to adulthood, and documentary evidence, along with genetic links found in dna tests of hemings and jefferson descendants in 1998, led most historians to believe. Over the years, however, belief in a thomas jeffersonsally hemings relationship was perpetuated in private. Background dna study thomas jefferson sally hemings. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father. Sallys eldest son was beverley, was born in 1798 and because of his age had a separate listing in the farm book.
Harriet hemings may 1801 1870 was born into slavery at monticello, the home of thomas jefferson, third president of the united states, in the first year of his presidency. On both sides of todays debate, as is also true in older considerations of the jeffersonhemings relationship, hemings is largely a ciphera blank slate on which any story can be written. Jefferson, hemings, and the evolution of racial mixing. For decades they hid jeffersons mistress now monticello. In the latter half of the 19th century, contradictory evidence surfaced. I read the first 1997 edition of this book, which appeared before the dna study was released. A perceptive analysis of thomas jefferson 17431826 by american historian henry adams emphasizes the contradictions and tensions between the philosophy, principles, and political practices of the third president of the united. Forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. The jeffersonhemings dna study as told by herbert barger, jefferson family historian. Madison hemings grew up on jeffersons monticello plantation. At the age of 68, madison hemings claimed the connection in his memoir published in 1873, which attracted national and international attention.
Monticello association the descendants of jeffersons daughters martha and mary for the last couple of years has invited hemings descendants to family reunions. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with. At the age of 68, madison hemings claimed the connection in an 1873 ohio newspaper interview, titled. This updated edition of the book also includes an afterword in which the author comments on the dna study that provided further evidence of a jefferson and hemings liaison. Dna evidence in 1998 supported the widely accepted conclusion that he was the son of thomas jefferson, the third president of the united states and the principal author of.
Eugene foster and published in the scientific journal nature in november 1998. An earlier child also named harriet had died in infancy. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father of all hemings children. Moreover, there is new dna available from madisons son william, but the. Largely as a result of revived interest in this case following gordonreeds book, a ydna analysis of carr, jefferson and hemings. A trial analysis of the evidence on paternity richard e. Thomas jefferson and sally hemings ohio university. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was likely the father of all hemings children. The best evidence for madison hemmingss report of a treaty that sally hemings negotiated with jefferson as her condition for agreeing to become his concubine in virginia is what happened to her children.
Yet all this attention sheds surprising little new light on her. The dna study did prove paternity of a jefferson family member and. In responding to letters to nature, the authors make it clear that the data establish only that thomas jefferson was one of several candidates for the paternity of. The subsequent availability of dna evidence that made it virtually certain that jefferson had fathered children by hemings shifted the ground, so much so that historians such as joseph ellis could. Dna evidence proves that thomas jefferson fathered at. In 1998, the journal nature reported that jefferson had a slave mistress sally hemings with whom he fathered six children, basing the claim on a pairing of historical records with dna evidence tracing ychromosomes. Given the absence of diaries, letters, paintings, or direct accounts from the subjects in the book that would provide direct evidence for such a project, this was a very tricky task. However, this attack ignores several key points, among which is the fact that the book of mormon states. The recent publication of the results of dna tests implies that eston hemings, sallys. Fawn brodies book on the subject received a good deal of criticism from. The dna evidence proves that thomas jefferson was the father of sallys youngest child, eston. Neither is madisons story consistent with the oral tradition in the family of his brother eston, who apparently passed down a claim that he was the son of a close relative of jefferson himself. The book also disputes accounts that hemings children received special treatment from jefferson, evidence some have used to suggest that the third.
Monticello association the descendants of jeffersons daughters martha and mary for the last couple of years has invited hemings descendants to. This is not the book to read if you want a strong attempt to develop a picture of sally hemings as a person it provides a better view of jefferson, in that sense. Dna testing of members of the jefferson and hemings families in. Gordonreeds approach is primarily to use the context of slavery, psychology, and business transaction ledgers to figure out what must of happened. He has stated this in emails to me, in nature journal january 7, 1999, the new york times article of early 1999 and in other publications. Madison hemings, born james madison hemings 18 january 1805 28 november 1877, was the son of the mixedrace slave sally hemings. James madison hemings january 18, 1805 november 28, 1877 was the son of the. The new information from the dna results supports ms.
Fosters statement that the dna evidence neither definitely excludes nor solely impliocates jefferson in the paternity of sally hemings children. In 1997, annette gordonreed published a book that analyzed the historiography of the controversy, demonstrating how historians since the nineteenth century had accepted early assumptions and failed to note all the facts. The society of madison descendants referred jackson and kearse to a commercial dnatesting website called family tree dna that they said contained the genetic records of madison relatives, wilson. Two of her childrenmadison and estonindicated that jefferson was their father, and this belief has been perpetuated in the oral histories of generations of their descendants as an important family truth. Eston hemings jefferson may 21, 1808 january 3, 1856 was born a slave at monticello, the youngest son of sally hemings, a mixedrace slave. Dna vs book of mormon incredible new evidence that proves the book of mormon. In the majority view, the dna evidence is consistent with jefferson being the father of eston hemings, plus the historical evidence favors jeffersons paternity for all of hemings children. The book caused a sensation in the sedate world of jefferson scholarship. Most historians believe her father was jefferson, who is now believed to have fathered, with his slave sally hemings, four children who survived to adulthood. An american tragedy 1997, she notes that prior to the dna results which showed that jefferson could be the father of eston hemings madisons brother. I would like to address the issue of the thomas jefferson dna study and give my first hand account regarding the misleading headline in the science journal nature dated november 5, 1998. He is interested in the basis on which science has been used by those who assert paternity, which involve the dna molecular findings, and the proximity theory, which is illustrated by a statistical study of jeffersons presence at monticello at the time of sally hemings conceptions.
All four of her children were allowed to leave monticello as free adults after they turned 21. Since jefferson had no adult sons by his marriage to wife martha, the team tested ychromosomal. He was the third of her four childrenfathered by her master, president thomas jeffersonto survive to adulthood. In the new introduction to her 1997 book thomas jefferson and sally hemings, she was careful to note that the dna test does not prove that the descendant of eston hemings sallys youngest child was a direct descendant of thomas jefferson, and she maintained this disclaimer all the way through the most recent printing in 2009. In november of 1998, following the release of dna tests which, combined with the historical record, strongly point to thomas jefferson as the father of at least one of sally hemingss children. Special video reports the history of a secret jeffersons blood. And according to madison hemings, jefferson began his sexual liaison with sally. A considerable body of evidence stretching from 1802 to 1873 and beyond describes thomas jefferson as the father of sally hemingss children. Has dna testing proved that thomasjefferson fathered at. Other evidence supports thomas jeffersons paternity as well, including his presence at. Four of hemingss children lived to adulthood, and documentary evidence, along with genetic links found in dna tests of hemings and jefferson descendants in 1998, led. Another testament of jesus christ, is true, not false. Jeffersonian democracy, books, articles, and internet commentaries continue. In november of 1998, following the release of dna tests which, combined with the historical record, strongly point to thomas jefferson as the father of at least one of sally hemingss children, the thomas jefferson memorial foundation formed a research committee to verify the findings, gather all relevant evidence.
Eugene a foster, et al, the thomas jefferson paternity case, nature, january 7, 1999. However, the same evidence proves that thomas jefferson was not the father of thomas woodson, said by some to be the oldest child of sally hemings. According to the new york times, there is a growing historical consensus among scholars that, as a widower, jefferson had a longterm relationship with hemings, and that he was the father of her six children, born after the death of his wife martha jefferson, who was the halfsister. Written by leaders in the fields of biology and statistics, the book emphasizes the interpretation of test results and provides the necessary formulae in an easily accessible manner. Madison hemings grew up on jeffersons monticello estate. Although they implicate a jefferson, not a carr, as eston hemings s father, the dna results cannot show that thomas jefferson was any more likely to have been estons father than any of thomass maleline relatives who might have had relations with sally hemings at the relevant times. No, the dna testing is inconclusive and, at best, proves only that any of thomas jeffersons male relatives could have fathered a child with sally hemings.
If jefferson had an affair with sally hemings, we have to. Over the last two centuries a debate has persisted concerning the level of intimacy thomas jefferson shared with sally hemings. Born into slavery by his mothers status, he was freed by the will of his master thomas jefferson in 1826. We can well doubt that sally hemings became pregnant in france and would have entered into the improbable treaty that madison described. The jefferson enigma jefferson post dna jeffersons blood. The jefferson miscegenation legend in british travel books. Many people, including some jefferson scholars, refused to accept the. The authors of the original dna report in nature say the evidence for thomas jeffersons paternity is less than conclusive. After the publication of the dna evidence, ellis, who wrote of himself as one of. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with sally.
Madison hemings memoirbut holowchak suggests that hemings peddled a. Most historians who have considered the question believe that his father was thomas jefferson, the united states president. Eston hemings jefferson was born to sally hemings, a mixedrace slave, on may 21, 1808 in monticello, virginia. The dna evidence is reasonably compelling on its own, establishing a perfect. Because of the dna evidence, world book encyclopedia mentioned hemings for the first time in its 1999 edition, spokesman mike weinstein said. To wit, was she a just another houseslave or, as madison hemings put it, jeffersons concubine. Since the only available dna evidence comes from direct male lineal descendants of persons who have descended from a common male line with thomas jefferson father, grandfather, etc. Annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth history. The hemings case against jefferson rests, essentially, on three skeletal pieces of evidence, framed by a selective exclusion of all the exculpatory evidence pointing to jeffersons innocence. That impels attention to the numerous other lines of evidence. Evidence from a 1998 dna test showed that a descendant of eston matched the jefferson male line, and historical evidence also. It was corroborated by the findings of the ychromosome haplotype dna study conducted by dr. Madison hemings, who learned carpentry at monticello, told the pike. A decade later, dna testing had evolved to include more information.
Gene edward veith, founders dna revisited, world, february 20, 1999. The announcement in 1998 that dna testing proved some link between the. It has had a very negative impact on the legacy of thomas jefferson and has. Shortly after it appeared, dna testing established a genetic link between a. Gordonreeds cautionary proposition that we should not ignore or discard any evidence simply because of its source.